Gold's Schizophrenia: Pulled Apart By Commodity And Safe Haven Status

Agustino Fontevecchia

www.forbes.com

Gold appears to have entered a new phase, acting as a hybrid, sometimes sympathizing with risk assets and other times acting like a safe haven, UBS' Edel Tully explains. While this makes it incredibly difficult to trade the yellow metal, the gold strategist remains bullish.

After falling about $20 on Tuesday in response to a stronger dollar, gold recovered its footing on Tuesday, hitting $1,693.90 an ounce, its highest level in two weeks. By 1:25 PM in New York, the yellow metal had given up some of those gains and was trading up $19.50 or 1.17% to $1,679.20 an ounce.

Gold's relentless climb, when any and all headlines seemed to fuel the precious metal's bull run, came to an end after peaking above $1,920 an ounce last August, falling almost 20% in a few weeks to bottom out around $1,562.

Still, the yellow metal remains up about 20% this year and most analysts remain bullish. It's as hard to explain gold's skyrocketing rise as it is its precipitous fall; UBS strategist Edel Tully notes gold is now behaving like a hybrid, acting as commodity or safe haven as investors try to find balance amid opposing forces.

Tully had said she expects gold to hit $1,920 in a month and $2,100 in three months, but recognizes gold's safe haven't status isn't keeping it afloat anymore. "Trading the yellow metal [has become] very challenging, as while one can have a view on an event such as US payrolls for example, deciphering how gold reacts has become a lot more difficult. And while buyers are nimbly returning, it is no surprise that there is caution given the struggle for conviction."

Regardless, gold will continue to react to macroeconomic news, particularly in Europe. While the yellow metal barely flinched in reaction to Slovakia's failure to ratify the EFSF (markets appear to factor in a positive vote sometime this week), the Merkel-Sarkozy "comprehensive package" could be setting investors up for a big disappointment, Tully says. "And considering how gold has been behaving recently, market reaction to euro-negative developments will not be as straightforward as it has been historically."

Gold miners have been an alternative to holding physical gold, either via an ETF or through the physical metal. Miners continue to under perform bullion, though, with the Market Vectors Gold Miners ETF flat in the last three months compared with a 5% gain for the GLD gold ETF. Barrick Gold, GoldCorp, and Freeport McMoran are among some of the underperformers within the mining group.